For a split second, Katie feels certain she s about to receive everything she s ever wanted . . . Twenty year old Katie Brenneman has always quietly fancied Jonathan Lundy. So when the broken hearted widower asks her to help him take care of his two young girls, Katie knows it will be a trying time but she cannot pass up a golden opportunity to get to know this man better. Just as she s settling into her new life, a message arrives from Katie s past, threatening to expose her darkest secrets. During her Rumspringa, her running around years, she experimented with activities forbidden in the Amish way of life. Frightened by how far she d strayed from her values, Katie ran back home, vowing to cut all ties with the outside world. Now her transgressions are coming back to haunt her, just as Jonathan seems willing to welcome her into his heart.